Stalin and the Fate of Europe: A Roundtable Discussion

U veljači 2021. godine održana je rasprava o knjizi Normana Naimarka “Stalin and the Fate of Europe: The Postwar Struggle for Sovereignty” u kojoj je sudjelovao i Tvrtko Jakovina. Snimku rasprave možete pogledati na YouTubeu.

Was the division of Europe after World War II inevitable? In this powerful reassessment of the postwar order in Europe, Norman Naimark suggests that Joseph Stalin was far more open to a settlement on the continent than we have thought. Through revealing case studies from Poland and Yugoslavia to Denmark and Albania, Naimark recasts the early Cold War by focusing on Europeans’ fight to determine their future. As nations devastated by war began rebuilding, Soviet intentions loomed large. Stalin’s armies controlled most of the eastern half of the continent, and in France and Italy, communist parties were serious political forces. Yet Naimark reveals a surprisingly flexible Stalin, who initially had no intention of dividing Europe. During a window of opportunity from 1945 to 1948, leaders across the political spectrum, including Juho Kusti Paasikivi of Finland, Wladyslaw Gomulka of Poland, and Karl Renner of Austria, pushed back against outside pressures. For some, this meant struggling against Soviet dominance. For others, it meant enlisting the Americans to support their aims. The first frost of Cold War could be felt in the tense patrolling of zones of occupation in Germany, but not until 1948, with the coup in Czechoslovakia and the Berlin Blockade, did the familiar polarization set in. The split did not become irreversible until the formal division of Germany and establishment of NATO in 1949. In illuminating how European leaders deftly managed national interests in the face of dominating powers, Stalin and the Fate of Europe reveals the real potential of an alternative trajectory for the continent.

Scholars from various European countries will provide commentaries on Norman Naimark’s recently published book, Stalin and the Fate of Europe: The Postwar Struggle for Sovereignty (Harvard University Press, 2019). Each commentator will address issues raised in the book and discuss points of contention, and Norman Naimark will then respond to the commentators. After the initial presentations, the seminar will be open to audience questions and discussion.

Tuesday, February 16, 2021, 12:30 –2pm EST

Live Video Stream


Cold War Studies Seminar


Norman M. Naimark, Robert and Florence McDonnel Professor of Eastern European Studies, Stanford University; Senior Fellow, Hoover Institution


Peter Ruggenthaler, Deputy Director, Boltzmann Institute for the Study of War’s Consequences (Austria)

Tvrtko Jakovina, Professor of Modern History, University of Zagreb

Vit Smetana, Senior Research Fellow, Institute for Contemporary History, Czech Academy of Sciences; Research Fellow, Institute of History, Hungarian Academy of Sciences

Miklós Mitrovits, Research Fellow, Institute of History, Hungarian Academy of Sciences


James G. Hershberg, Professor of History, George Washington University